(photo submitted to the Sacramento Bee by Nan-Hui Jo; graphic design by Dillon Sung)
In July 2014, Nan-Hui Jo, a single Korean mother and survivor of domestic violence, was separated from her six year old daughter, Vitz Da, and arrested on claims of child abduction. In 2009, Nan-Hui fled to Korea with Vitz Da to escape physical and emotional abuse by her then-partner and father of the child, a combat veteran of the Iraq War with PTSD and anger issues. Using a common manipulation tactic to control a partner’s attempts to regain independence, her former partner retaliated by reporting Nan-Hui for child abduction. Last July, when Nan-Hui arrived with her daughter to Hawaii, she was handcuffed, arrested, and immediately separated from her daughter. Nan-Hui has not seen her daughter in over seven months.
Nan-Hui’s former partner has publicly testified about his repeated violence against her confirming that on one occasion, he “grabbed her by the throat and threw her against the wall.” He has also, on two separate occasions, broken his hand while punching the wall by her head, and again when punching the car’s steering wheel when she was in the car with him. When Nan-Hui fled and attempted to rebuild her life, he “sent emails saying he was ‘considering spending thousands of dollars on a scary bounty hunter.’” These incidents of violence are only the public ones against Nan-Hui. Like many survivors of domestic violence, Nan-Hui was concerned that if he had hurt her, that he would hurt the child. According to a study funded by the U.S. Department of Justice, 30 to 60% of perpetrators of intimate partner violence also abuse children in the household. As advocates for survivors of domestic violence, we know that domestic violence thrives behind closed doors, away from the eyes and ears of the public.
Domestic violence is not just physical violence; it often involves “coercive control, economic abuse, emotional abuse, and/or sexual violence. It is intended to gain or maintain power and control over a romantic or intimate partner to intimidate, frighten, terrorize, humiliate, blame, or injure”. Nan-Hui’s former partner’s behavior and patterns of violence fit well into the prototypes of abusive partners, using different forms of power to control, manipulate, and smear their partners. Conflict in relationships is normal. Punching walls and hitting steering wheels to intimidate your partner, strangling your partner and throwing her against the wall, and threatening to use a bounty hunter is a pattern of abuse and violent behavior.
Five months after being arrested, Nan-Hui was tried on December 15, 2014, for “child abduction.” This trial resulted in a hung jury. The District Attorney, Steve Mount, however, pursued a retrial, refusing to acknowledge the importance of domestic violence in Nan-Hui’s case and instead, has used all resources available to prosecute her. Instead of being granted protection, survivors of domestic violence are often criminalized: the ACLU reports that of all incarcerated women in the United States, 85-90% have a history of domestic and sexual abuse. Survivors of domestic violence should not be punished for defending themselves, protecting their children, and rebuilding their lives from the violence of an abuser.
Nan-Hui has been in jail since the arrest without due process, has now been separated from Vitz Da for over seven months, and has now been convicted of “child abduction.” These punitive measures show little concern for the welfare of either child or mother. Nan-Hui and her daughter have an incredibly close and caring relationship, and to Nan-Hui, Vitz Da is her whole world. After a stillbirth earlier in her life, Nan-Hui was told that she would never be able to conceive again. When she was pregnant, she considered her daughter a miracle. Giving grace to the birth of her daughter, Nan-Hui named her her Vitz Da, meaning “all light in Korean”. Vitz Da, who was fully immersed into Korean society for most of her life, has been abruptly disallowed any contact with her mother. Vitz Da is currently in full custody of the father, and Nan-Hui has not been able to speak with her daughter since July.
Nan Hui’s retrial has ended and she has been convicted of “child abduction.” The sentencing hearing was initially to take place on April 1, 2015. The sentencing date has now been moved to April 28th at 1:30PM. We have been notified that there is an immigration hold on Nan-Hui Jo so after sentencing, immediate deportation proceedings could take effect which would separate Nan-Hui from her daughter permanently. CBP and ICE have the power of prosecutorial discretion to drop the hold on Nan-Hui so she can stay in the US to attend future custody hearings.
We are deeply disturbed at how aggressively the Yolo County District Attorney’s Office, CBP (Customs & Border Protection), and ICE(Immigration & Customs Enforcement) is working to prosecute, criminalize and deport a single immigrant mother and survivor of domestic violence.
Stand with us in supporting Nan-Hui and demand justice for all survivors of domestic violence. Sign the new petition, share her story, and send a strong message to CBO, ICE, Yolo County, and our Congressional leaders that survivors of domestic violence must be supported, not criminalized and keep mother and child together!
CBP and ICE, exercise prosecutorial discretion and drop the immigration hold on Nan-Hui! No deportation!
Free Nan-Hui Jo and reunite her with her daughter!
End the criminalization of survivors!
March 3, 2015
For Immediate Release
- Hyejin Shim, KACEDA
- Orchid Pusey, Asian Women’s Shelter
- Nilda Valmores, My Sister’s House
- Beverly Upton, Domestic Violence Consortium
Nan-Hui Jo Convicted of Child Abduction Charges;
Community protests conviction of Nan-Hui Jo, survivor of domestic violence
March 3, 2015—Supporters of Nan-Hui Jo express their outrage and sadness over her conviction for child abduction. With the conviction, Jo is currently being threatened with deportation, despite having pending immigration applications on file. Korean community groups, domestic violence organizations, student groups and concerned community members have rallied for Jo by attending the trial, bringing attention to the case through Facebook and Twitter (#StandWithNanHui, #WeSurvived), and circulating a petition demanding Immigration and Custom Enforcement (ICE) and Custom and Border Protection (CBP) to exercise their prosecutorial discretion and drop her deportation case. If Jo is deported, she could be permanently separated from her child.
Jo is a survivor of domestic violence. Jo left the United States with her child, Vitz Da, in 2009, to escape physical and emotional abuse from the child’s father. When she returned to the United States in July 2014, she was immediately arrested and separated from her child. In December 2014, Jo was tried for child abduction, and this trial resulted in a hung jury. The Yolo County District Attorney ignored the domestic violence her child’s father testified and publicly admitted to and aggressively pursued a retrial of Jo, which commenced February 20, 2015. Throughout this entire process, Jo has been denied the right to see her daughter, while the child’s father was given full custody of Vitz Da. Jo has been in jail without bail due to the immigration hold and has not seen her daughter in over seven months.
“We are extremely disappointed in the verdict. As advocates for survivors of domestic violence, we believe that this case should not have even been prosecuted. We continue to be inspired by Nan-Hui Jo’s strength throughout this time and will be continuing the fight to ensure she is reunited with her daughter,” says Hyejin Shim of Korean American Coalition to End Domestic Abuse (KACEDA), a domestic violence organization based in the Bay Area. KACEDA, Immigrant Youth Coalition, and Asian Law Caucus are asking community members to sign their petition and to call San Francisco ICE and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) field offices to drop Jo’s deportation case at bit.ly/standwithnanhui
The Community Coalition Against Domestic Violence in Sacramento and KACEDA have also set up a fundraising campaign to help cover Jo legal fees and other costs related to her appeal and pending immigration hearing and child custody hearing. To contribute to this fund, go to https://crowddefend.com/campaign/stand-with-nan-hui-2/#